Major Case Investigation
The LOSER Principle
Listen, Observe, Search, Evaluate, Record
- Listen
- Depending on the part you play in the investigation, will determine who you have to listen to, so lets review the roles of the players and possible contributors of that information: ???
- Observe
- Even before you get to the scene you should be attentive to surroundings, especially vehicles and people in the general area, so lets once again discuss what we see and how it is interpreted: ???
- Search
- Before we search lets secure the area if it has not already been done, so what do we use: ??? Depending on the size of the area to be searched will dictate the type of procedure we utilise so lets talk about standard practices and obviously the amount of personnel available to assist:???
- Evaluate
- What information have we gathered since notified of the incident, what has changed, what has happened, what do we hope the outcome will be so once again lets review what we have but remember we have only one chance to get it right, so do it right the first time: ???
- Record
-
- I have a good memory, so why do I have to record what I am doing and what method do you want me to use ?
- Lets consider it may be three to four years before this case gets to court and if you think that it will be the only one you are involved with, good luck.
- How do we keep track of any evidence that is seized or developed and who is responsible for it’s security ?
What is a ‘Major Case’?
The following criteria offences are deemed to be major cases:
- Homicides as defined in subsection 222(4), Criminal Code of Canada, and attempts
- Sexual assaults, and all attempts (includes sexual interference, exploitation and touching)
- Occurrences involving non-familial abductions & attempts
- Missing person occurrences, where circumstances indicate a strong possibility of foul play
- Occurrences suspected to be homicide involving found human remains
- Criminal harassment cases in which the offender is not known to the victim
- Any other case designated as a major case by the Major Case Management Executive Board
Major Case Identification System
The process of early detection & linkages.
Achieved through:
- Violent Crime Linkage Analysis Software (ViCLAS)
- Centre of Forensic Sciences (CFS)
- DNA Data Bank
- Office of the Chief Coroner
- Canadian Police Information Centre (CPIC)
- Major Case Management Software –PowerCase
- Serial Predatory Crime Investigator
- Ontario Sex Offender Registry
ViCLAS
Automated case linkage system designed to capture, collate and compare crimes of violence through the analysis of victimology, offender/suspect description, modus operandi, forensic and behavioral data
Forensic Services & Coroner’s Complex
- Centre of Forensic Sciences
- Provide scientific laboratory services in support of the administration of justice and public safety
- Office of the Chief Coroner
- Central repository of all death reports that have been investigated by all Coroners throughout the Province of Ontario
DNA Data Bank
National repository for DNA profiles of unknown DNA samples from crime scenes and profiles of offenders convicted of designated offences (Results as of 31 January 2017).
- Receives ~500-600 samples per week. Proclaimed 30 Jun 2000
- Offender hits; Crime Scene to Offender; 43,563
- Forensic hits; Crime Scene to Crime Scene; 4969
Canadian Police Information Centre (CPIC)
National repository of data on charged, wanted, missing persons, stolen vehicles, property and other crime-related data
Power Case
Ministry approved - Major Case Management Software
- Centralized and secure data storage
- Evidence management
- Research
- Assign and track lines of investigation
- Intelligence analysis
- Court preparation
Serial Predatory Crime Investigator (SPCI)
Responsible for the review, development and coordination of multi-jurisdictional and single jurisdiction investigations of linked major cases
When “a reasonable likelihood” exists that the same person(s) has committed the crimes. When that criterion is met, the SPCI co-ordinator is notified and becomes part of the probe.
Daren Millard is a prime example of this area of responsibility
Ontario Sex Offender Registry
Provincial legislation which requires convicted offenders to, on court order, report and supply local police services with their current address and notify police of any address change
- Christopher’s Law
- April 23, 2001 –Ontario first and only to establish registry
Bill 163 (2013), amended legislation, adding:
- Reporting obligations - to enable the province to require offenders to report within seven days instead of the current 15
- The addition of offenders convicted outside of Canada, and
- The addition of offenders pardoned under the Criminal Records Act
Inter-disciplinary Approach
- Forensic Identification Officers
- Forensic pathology
- Forensic odontology / dentistry
- Forensic anthropology / archaeology
- Forensic Entomology
- Pattern / wound interpretation
- Other medical experts
- Other forensic experts
- CFS
- Climatology, Knot analysis
Death Investigation Case
Public service functions
- Identifying epidemics of infectious disease
- Inheritance recipient
- Forensic aspect is determining cause/manner of death:
- Cause of death is the disease / injury responsible for the lethal sequence of events
- Manner of death explains how the cause of death arose
- Mechanism of death is the process (physiological / biochemical) leading to death
Pronouncing Death
- Pre-stethoscopes
- Tongue and nipple pulling
- Tobacco smoke enemas
- Insertion of hot pokers into various bodily orifices
- 17th century
- Waiting mortuaries
- Stethoscope (1816)
- Presence/absence of a heartbeat
- EKG
- CPR (20th century)
Time of Death
The time of method is only an estimate, and used in conjunction with other methods.
Stages of Death | Postmortem Changes | Time Since Death |
---|---|---|
Rigor mortis | Stiffening | 4hrs; 24-36hrs |
Livor mortisㅤㅤㅤㅤㅤㅤ | Settling ㅤㅤㅤㅤㅤㅤㅤㅤㅤㅤㅤㅤ | Minutes; 36hrs (fixed at 12hrs) ㅤㅤㅤㅤㅤㅤㅤㅤㅤㅤㅤㅤ |
Algor mortis | Cooling | Variable |
Team Players
- Medical Examiner ( A term used in USA only)
- Coroner
- Forensic Pathologists
Canadian Coroners
There are two systems.
- Jurisdiction of Provincial/Territorial government
- Coroner = Medical Examiner (depends where)
- Coroners are not necessarily physicians (B.C. Sask. Que. N.B. Nw.T. Nun. Yuk.)
Do not determine civil or criminal responsibility, rather that make and offer recommendations. Why?
- Improve public safety
- Prevention of similar future deaths
Ontario Coroners
- Coroners in Ontario are medical doctors with specialized training in death investigation
- Available to the community 24 hrs a day / 7 days a week
- Coroners report to the Chief Coroner who is responsible for all coroners in Ontario
- Coroners investigate deaths that happen under certain
circumstances as determined by a provincial law called the
Coroners Act of Ontario
Currently have dual leadership
- Office of the Chief Coroner & Ontario Forensic Pathology Service
Coroner vs Pathologist
Coroner | Pathologist |
---|---|
Oversee / governing body | Conducts autopsy |
Determine cause of death | Provides autopsy report to Coroner |
The coroner will consider the pathologist’s report and other investigative findings, in determining the cause and manner of death | Specialized doctors |
Ontario Forensic Pathology Service
- Dr. Michael Pollanen, Chief Forensic Pathologist
- ~6000 autopsies/year (coroner-ordered)
- Kingston, London, Ottawa, Sault Ste. Marie, Sudbury and Toronto
The Investigation
- Certification
- Identify
- Cause & Manner of Death
- Manner of Death: natural, accident, suicide, homicide, undetermined
- Cause of death: “results in”, temporal delay not relevant
- Investigation
- Collection of Samples
- Timing, mechanism, contributing factors
- Correlation of evidence
Autopsy
Postmortem examination - a process whereby a pathologist or forensic pathologist examines the decedent’s body to help determine cause of death.
- Internal & External examination
- Incision
- Removal of skull cap
- Major organs are examined & sampled
Manners of Death
- Natural
- Death that is due to a natural disease or a
complication
- Disease (not injury) is the sole cause of death
- Accident
- Death due to an incident or injury
- Suicide
- Death resulting from an intentional act & personal act
- Homicide
- Death resulting from an intentional act at the hands of another
- Undetermined
- Conflicting or lack evidence
Natural | Trauma | Drugs & Alcohol |
---|---|---|
Ischemiaㅤㅤㅤㅤㅤㅤㅤ | Mechanicalㅤㅤㅤㅤㅤㅤㅤ | Alcoholsㅤㅤㅤㅤㅤㅤㅤ |
Hemorrhage | Thermal | Street |
Infection | Chemical | OTC |
Electrical | Prescription |
Traumatic Deaths
Mechanical Traumatic Death
- Sharp Force Trauma
- Produces incised wounds
- Blunt Force Trauma
-
- Non-firearm
- Fierarm: low, medium, high velocity
Chemical Traumatic Death
Chemical deaths can be from various causes such as:
- Alcohol
- Street drugs
- Poisoning
Indicators of chemical death include:
- Bright red blood as a sign of carbon monoxide poisoning
- A green brain as a sign of exposure to hydrogen sulfide
- Chocolate brown blood as a sign of excess methemoglobin poisoning
- Hair falling out can be a sign of chronic arsenic or thallium poisoning
- Blue skin can be a sign of gadolinium poisoning •Cocaine and methamphetamines can change the shape of the heart
Thermal Traumatic Death
- Exposure to excessive heat or cold
- Hypothermia (excessive cold)
- Alcohol intoxication
- Hyperthermia (excessive heat)
- Young and elderly
Electrical Traumatic Death
- Ventricular fibrillation
- Low voltage
- Alternating current
- Defibrillatory
- Higher voltages
- Electrical burns
- Poration
Asphyxias
- Interruption of oxygenation to the brain
- Chemical & Thermal
- Drowning
- Strangulation: manual & ligature
- Autopsy findings
- Hyoid bone / cornu of thyroid cartilage & hemorrhaging around fracture site